From May through October 2026, Hamilton County recorded mid-century house sales on the streets around Cinderella Drive in Montgomery at $358,000 to $535,900. Over roughly the same months, older condominium units on Montgomery Road sold for $180,000 to $340,000, and attached homes on Shakertown Court and Shakerdale Road sold for $280,000 to $365,000. This fall, Traditions Group is selling the final building of single-floor condominiums at The Wicks at Vintage Club, with prices starting at $695,000.
Those figures show where Montgomery's prices jump. The low-maintenance homes that cost less than a mid-century house are older attached homes without an elevator, underground parking or a clubhouse. The ones that have those features start above what most mid-century houses sell for. For a typical owner on those streets, a smaller and easier home with an elevator costs more than the house they are leaving. Downsizing in Montgomery usually means deciding which features you are willing to pay extra for.
The 2026 options, by what each one costs
| Option | What it is | 2026 price evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Montgomery Road condos | Older condominium units at 10555 and 10667 Montgomery Rd | $180,000 to $340,000 in recorded sales, January to October |
| Shakertown Ct and Shakerdale Rd | Attached homes the county classifies as P.U.D. | $220,000 to $365,000 in recorded sales, January to October |
| Vintage Club resale condos | Condominium units on Vintage Club Dr and Blvd | $640,000 and $895,000 in the first half of the year |
| The Wicks, new | Single-floor condos with elevator and underground parking | From $695,000, final building |
| Capstone, new | Brownstones and detached homes with first-floor primary suites | From $1 million |
| Montgomery Quarter, rental | Apartments and townhome-style rentals | $1,609 to $4,129 a month starting rents |
| Trillium at Twin Lakes | Independent-living homes | $1.15M to $1.25M entrance fee plus a monthly fee |
Sources for each row appear in the sections below. The sale figures are Hamilton County Auditor transfer records from January through October 28, 2026.
The mid-century streets set the budget most sellers bring
Most downsizers start by selling the family home, and that sale sets what they can spend next. On the streets around Cinderella Drive, which include Storybook Drive, Bookmark Place and Kerrianna Drive, most recorded sales from May through October 2026 fell between $450,000 and $535,900, with a few lower, down to $358,000.
For comparison, the REALTOR Alliance of Greater Cincinnati put the regional median sold price at $309,000 for October 2026, with a median of 14 days on market. Montgomery's mid-century homes sell well above the regional median. Even so, a seller on these streets who clears around $500,000 is about $195,000 short of the lowest new price at The Wicks.
Below that budget are older condos and attached homes
Montgomery's lowest-priced low-maintenance homes are in two clusters of older attached housing. Condominium units at 10555 and 10667 Montgomery Road recorded sales from $180,000 to $340,000 between January and October 2026.
The attached homes on Shakertown Court and Shakerdale Road form the second cluster. The Hamilton County Auditor classifies them under land-use code 555, P.U.D. or "landominium," which is separate from the code for a standard condominium unit. Recorded sales there ran from $220,000 to $365,000 between January and October 2026.
A seller coming from Cinderella Drive could buy any of these and keep a large share of the proceeds. These homes sell close to the regional median. They do not have the features the higher-priced options are built around, such as an elevator to the unit, parking under the building or a clubhouse in the community.
The elevator costs about $640,000 and up
The Vintage Club is Montgomery's planned community for owners who want less house without giving up finishes. Traditions Group describes it as a 68-acre master-planned community with the Three Chimneys Clubhouse, a pool and a fitness center. Resale condominium prices there started where the town's mid-century homes topped out. Two condominium units in the community resold in the first half of 2026, for $640,000 and $895,000. Single-family homes in the community sold for $2 million and more.
New construction raises the floor. The final building at The Wicks has 18 residences starting at $695,000. Each is a single-floor unit in a three-story stone and brick building with a secured-access elevator, two underground parking spaces and two storage rooms. Other listed features include 10-foot ceilings, Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, and a courtyard, balcony or penthouse terrace. The builder also points to the walk to Harper's shopping and Good Shepherd Church.
Capstone, the last phase of the Vintage Club, starts at $1 million. The City of Montgomery's September 2025 bulletin placed it on the southern hillside behind the Christ Hospital Outpatient Center. The bulletin described brownstone-style townhomes with rear-entry garages along Vintage Club Boulevard, optional elevators and rooftop terraces, and detached homes with first-floor primary suites and walk-out lower levels. Traditions lists about 3,000 to 3,600 square feet for the Brownstones and about 3,500 to 4,900 for the Bayhill homes. The largest Bayhill plan can be bigger than the house its buyer is leaving, so a Capstone buyer is choosing a first-floor primary suite over a smaller footprint.
At these prices, a seller on Cinderella Drive is trading up in cost. Moving to the cheapest new unit at The Wicks means adding roughly $160,000 to $245,000 to a 2026 sale in the $450,000 to $535,900 range. Owners selling larger homes elsewhere in Montgomery are in a different position. Several Montgomery single-family sales between June and October 2026 closed between about $1.4 million and $1.75 million. For sellers at those prices, The Wicks frees up cash.
Monthly options, with no house to maintain
Some Montgomery owners skip buying entirely. The Residences at Montgomery Quarter list one-bedroom apartments starting at $1,609 to $2,616 a month and two-bedrooms starting at $2,559 to $4,129. A two-bedroom townhome-style plan starts at $2,909, and the operator's site showed its two-bedroom plans on a waitlist in mid-November. At that townhome rent, a year costs about $34,900. The property has a pool, a 24-hour fitness center, secure garage parking and in-unit washers and dryers. More rentals are coming. The City's November 1 update reported construction underway on 239 more apartments by Hills Properties. The same update noted that ClarkDietrich's new headquarters is going up in the same phase of Montgomery Quarter.
Trillium at Twin Lakes is the highest-priced option on the list. The City's November update reported that its 30 independent-living homes on Don Neyer Way are completed and fully reserved. The community keeps a waitlist. The Trillium page lists the 2,108-square-foot Hawthorn plan with a 2026 monthly fee of $5,605 and a 90% refundable entrance fee of $1,150,000. The 2,367-square-foot Laurel plan has a $5,874 monthly fee and a $1,250,000 entrance fee. The monthly fee covers real estate taxes, utilities, insurance on the home's structure, interior and exterior maintenance, lawn care and snow removal. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and readers should confirm how any fee or contract applies to them with the right professional.
The sale price of your current home decides the move
Because the easy-living options start so far above the mid-century price range, the sale of your current home decides what comes next. On streets where 2026 sales spread from $358,000 to $535,900, a sale near the top of that range rather than the bottom closes much of the distance to The Wicks.
The rest of Montgomery is also changing around these choices. The City's November update reported that the Montgomery Inn finished an interior renovation and that the former Village Hall building is being turned into a cocktail bar. Owners who want to stay near the Historic District and Montgomery Quarter will be looking at the options above, at the prices above. More on the town is on our Montgomery neighborhood page. Sellers starting to plan can read our guide on how to prepare a Montgomery home for market.
A few direct answers
What is the least expensive way to own a low-maintenance home in Montgomery? In 2026, the condominium units at 10555 and 10667 Montgomery Road sold for $180,000 to $340,000 between January and October, the lowest prices among Montgomery's attached homes.
Can I buy a resale home in the Vintage Club instead of new construction? Yes, when units come up. Two Vintage Club condominium units resold in the first half of 2026, for $640,000 and $895,000.
Are new for-sale homes still available at the Vintage Club? Traditions Group is selling the final building at The Wicks, from $695,000, and the Capstone phase, from $1 million.
If you are weighing a Montgomery Road condo against The Wicks, start with what your current home will sell for. The Julia Wesselkamper Group can give you a considered estimate of your home's value and a plan to get it ready for market, including complimentary staging for listed homes. Contact us to talk through your next move in Montgomery.